Choosing a Fleet Management Information System (FMIS) like Fleetio is only the beginning of building a connected, efficient fleet operation. The true test lies in implementing that system within the constraints of tight budgets, demanding crews, and complex regulations. Fleet managers face daily challenges ranging from maintenance approvals and data accuracy to driver compliance and vendor “contract fatigue.”

This guide explores common fleet management challenges and offers practical solutions drawn from proven lessons and real-world experiences from fleet leaders. Using Fleetio as a case study, it shows how a well-implemented FMIS, supported by the right processes and culture, can boost efficiency, control costs, and maintain compliance.

‍

1. How to Streamline Maintenance Approvals to Control Costs and Reduce Downtime

‍

Critical Impact: Inefficient, ad-hoc approval processes often result in hidden costs, operational delays, and uncontrolled scope creep.

Fleet operators consistently report that managing maintenance approvals is a significant operational bottleneck. For fleets that outsource repairs, the process typically involves a frustrating series of phone calls and emails between shops and managers. This outdated method leads to miscommunication, delays, and unapproved expenses, leaving managers searching for a way to get vehicles back in service without blindly approving every charge.

Before bringing maintenance in house, Chuck Metoyer, Fleet Manager, Abt, was farming out service to different shops which was problematic when trying to track down service information.

‍“It was kinda rough back then because I was just using an excel spreadsheet to keep track of everything, [so it] was really, really hard to keep track of stuff. It became an issue [of], ‘Who did repairs last?’ when we have a problem where it’s a comeback job,” says Chuck. “Now you gotta remember who the hell you had to do the work and then bring it back to the right shop [and not] blame the wrong guy.”

When a repair shop discovers additional issues, the vehicle sits idle, waiting for approval. This "phone tag" not only extends costly downtime but also creates the risk of over-scoped work. Many fleets lack formal approval thresholds, leading to unexpected and inflated invoices. 

One fleet professional offered a critical piece of advice: always test an FMIS approval workflow. Discovering that a system failed to flag a missing purchase order at the invoicing stage could be a costly mistake. The key takeaway is to test the FMIS with real-world scenarios to ensure it catches budget or PO discrepancies before they become financial problems.

Modern Solutions That Work

‍

A modern fleet management software like Fleetio directly tackles this issue with digital work orders and integrated approval workflows. Instead of fragmented communication, all repair estimates and tasks are consolidated in a central system. Managers can set line-item approval thresholds, automatically triggering a supervisor review for any part or repair exceeding a set amount. This provides direct oversight and prevents unauthorized spending.

A well-designed workflow allows you to review estimates, cross-reference them with vehicle service history, and approve, deny, or request changes in just a few clicks. A Fleetio user noted that this feature provided much tighter control over both maintenance scope and cost, creating a permanent digital trail for every approval.

The primary benefit is the combination of speed and accountability. Fleetio’s acquisition of the maintenance authorization platform Auto Integrate highlights a key industry trend. It enables shops to submit electronic repair orders directly to the fleet manager for approval and communicate within those digital orders when unexpected issues arise during routine maintenance. This makes the process more transparent, trackable, and significantly reduces communication time.

When integrated into an FMIS, a manager receives an alert, reviews the work order, and takes action within the system. The entire process is logged, and vehicles return to service faster.

Best Practices for Implementation:

• Establish Clear Policies: Define what requires approval and designate who has authority (e.g., repairs over $1,000 need manager sign-off).
• Mandate Digital Work Orders: Onboard all vendors and internal technicians to ensure every repair starts as a digital work order. Verbal approvals are not enough.
• Leverage Comment Threads: Use work-order comments for transparent communication (e.g., justifying a repair or attaching photos) to maintain a clear digital paper trail.
• Red Flag to Watch For: An FMIS with no line-item approvals or change history on estimates is a major red flag.

‍

2. How to Ensure Strong Vendor Support and Internal User Buy-In

‍

Critical Impact: Even the most powerful software will fail if the vendor is unresponsive or the internal team doesn't adopt it.

Real-World Pain Points: Many fleet professionals have invested in an FMIS only to be met with a steep learning curve and poor vendor support. One technician mentioned that while their software worked, it was not intuitive. Another user took two years to become proficient, discovering that the web interface was better suited to their needs than the mobile app. The lesson is that proficiency takes time, training, and support.

“Throughout my career, I’ve had the experience of, in some way, shape or form, implementing new technology and new fleet software," says Tom Rowlings, Assistant Fleet Manager, City of Cambridge. “Most fleet softwares have similar functionalities regarding what the end result is, but it’s how you get to the end result and how user-friendly the interface is that’s important."

‍

Internally, strong governance is non-negotiable. A lack of standardized processes or too many system administrators can corrupt inventory data and vehicle records, leading to major discrepancies.

Modern Adoption Strategies:

• Vet Vendor Support: Choose vendors with comprehensive support and robust training resources.
• Create Internal Champions: Involve mechanics and drivers in the selection process and pilot programs to build early buy-in.
• Implement Continuous Training: Host regular, short training sessions (e.g., a "Fleetio Friday" 15-minute knowledge share) to reinforce best practices.
• Lead by Example: Leadership should run meetings using FMIS dashboards and publicly recognize employees for accurate data entry.

‍

3. How to Maintain Data Integrity for Accurate Fleet Records

‍

Critical Impact: Inaccurate data,"garbage in, garbage out", directly compromises safety, cost control, and regulatory compliance.

Real-World Pain Points: Audits consistently show that poor data leads to missed preventive maintenance (PM), lost assets, financial errors, and compliance violations. Common examples include:

• Missing warranty information.
• Unreliable inventory counts from unrestricted adjustments.
• Inaccurate meter readings that disrupt PM schedules.

• Integrate and Automate: Sync your FMIS with telematics for real-time odometer updates and integrate fuel card data to automatically flag anomalies (e.g., a 50-gallon fill-up for a sedan).
• Enforce Permissions and Validation: Utilize required fields, audit trails, granular user roles, and immutable change logs to protect data integrity.
• Conduct Regular Audits: Run exception reports to identify issues, such as vehicles with no meter updates in 30 days or work orders with a $0 cost.
• Attach Source Documents: Link original invoices, inspection forms, and photos to work orders for a complete, audit-ready record.
• A Lesson from Peers: Design your system so that "the right thing is easy, and the wrong thing is hard." Require that parts are tied to work orders and adjustments require evidence. Unbiased data empowers objective lifecycle decisions, free from OEM influence.

‍

Additional Fleet Management Challenges

‍

• Rightsizing FMIS for Fleets: Finding a scalable solution that balances powerful functionality with simplicity for fleets with limited technical resources.
• Managing Driver Behavior: Improving driver compliance and engagement, as the human element is crucial to the success of any fleet initiative.
• Avoiding Vendor Contract Fatigue: Streamlining vendor relationships to avoid overwhelming managers and secure optimal terms.
• Staying Ahead of Regulatory Demands: Proactively managing evolving compliance requirements to avoid costly violations and penalties.
• Integrating Systems for a Unified View: Building a connected tech stack without creating single points of failure.
• Navigating OEM Lifecycle Bias: Using data-driven insights to make objective asset management decisions.

‍

Your Fleet Software and Analytics Partner: Fleetio & Utilimarc

Managing a modern fleet requires understanding the data behind every decision. We understand that adopting new technology can be daunting. Our partnership extends far beyond the point of sale. With over 20 years of experience, our team of experts provides the heavy lifting, from implementation and integration to training and long-term support to serve as your dedicated fleet optimization team.

The value of this partnership is proven by tangible results:

‍

• Quantifiable Savings: One large utility fleet achieved $1M in annual savings through asset rightsizing, while reporting automation eliminated over 1,200 annual labor hours.
• Faster ROI: Our integrated solutions deliver predictive insights and automation that often achieve a payback period of less than 12 months.
• Expert Partnership: With deep domain expertise and a 98% client retention rate, our dedicated analysts function as an extension of your team.
• Data You Can Trust: Our in-house team cleans, normalizes, and validates your data, ensuring you can make strategic decisions with confidence.

With Fleetio as the operational backbone and Utilimarc as the analytics engine, fleets don't just run, they run smarter.

Want better results from your fleet software?

‍Connect with our team to get started.