Evaluating Telematics Providers: A Strategic Overview

Telematics is a cornerstone of effective fleet management—providing the real-time insight fleets need to operate safely, efficiently, and strategically. Far beyond basic tracking, today’s telematics systems collect rich data on vehicle performance, driver behavior, fuel consumption, idling, and more. This enables fleet leaders to identify risky driving habits, coach proactively, prevent mechanical failures through early diagnostics, and reduce unnecessary miles and fuel use with dynamic routing.

When integrated with video, telematics also adds valuable context to events like harsh braking or collisions, helping ensure fair and constructive feedback.

But the value of telematics depends entirely on how it's set up, supported, and integrated. Even the most advanced hardware can fall short if it’s not configured properly or connected to the rest of your systems. Incomplete, inaccurate, or hard-to-access data undermines decision-making. That’s why data quality, system integration, and visibility across platforms are just as important as the devices themselves.

And the difference often comes down to your provider. Some vendors offer hardware at a low cost, but leave fleets with hidden expenses, limited support, poor data access, or weak integration. Others act as true partners—ensuring the right technology is selected, implemented properly, and configured to deliver clean, unified data you can actually use.

When you choose the right partner, telematics becomes more than a tool—it becomes a foundation for smarter operations, better decisions, and lasting results. View our interactive checklist to help you evaluate telematics providers.

‍

The Hidden Costs Of The Wrong Telematics Partner

Installation, integration and training burdens
Telematics devices are not plug‑and‑play in every vehicle. Installing systems that are incompatible with a vehicle’s engine control module can require additional wiring harnesses and cause operational issues; downtime from these problems can be costly.

Complicated software also increases training time. Systems that are difficult to use or require extensive training can quickly negate savings. A poor user experience forces staff to fall back on spreadsheets and manual processes.

Inaccurate reporting and poor AI detection
Telematics is only as good as its data. Inaccurate artificial‑intelligence detection misrepresents driver behavior and delays coaching.

When a system misses warnings or incorrectly flags safe drivers, fleets must dedicate staff to review and verify events, increasing labour costs. Such inaccuracies can also undermine driver trust and erode the safety benefits telematics is supposed to deliver.

Lack of proactive customer support
Reliable support is critical for managing hardware failures, software updates and system customization. Vendors that provide weak or outsourced customer service leave fleets with extended downtime and frustrated users.

Hidden costs also arise when vendors charge for data exports or additional reports; poor reporting structures often force fleets to invest in separate analytics tools to extract insights.

Security and privacy exposure
Telematics systems collect sensitive data, including location histories and driving behavior. Poor security exposes fleets to unauthorized access, malware and data interception. Without strong encryption, authentication and regular software updates, telematics units can become targets for hackers.

Driver apprehension and privacy concerns
Drivers often view cameras and telematics as intrusive. To avoid resistance, organizations must develop privacy guidelines based on legitimacy (collecting only data aligned with stated purposes), transparency (clearly communicating data use and access) and early stakeholder engagement. The right partner can help you to leverage best practices for adoption and onboarding.

The Blueprint: 7 Qualities Of An Excellent Telematics Partner

1. Proactive support and training
Telematics should come with hands-on support, not just a help‑desk ticket. A vendor should provide proactive guidance, help set up custom rules and dashboards, and offer training for drivers and fleet managers.

Thorough onboarding prevents under‑utilization and frustration. Ongoing support ensures that integration problems are resolved quickly and that new features are adopted effectively.

2. Scalability and flexibility
The telematics solution must grow with your fleet. Look for systems like Geotab that can handle an increasing number of vehicles, incorporate electric vehicles, automate manual tasks and operate across multiple facilities.

Choose a provider with a roadmap that aligns with your long‑term goals and is willing to enhance the solution after implementation and configure it for your specific needs.

3. Integration with existing systems
Telematics should never act as another isolated platform or source of information. Ask vendors how well their system integrates with maintenance, fuel management and safety systems.

Clumsy workarounds or manual exports are red flags. Industry guides advise ensuring your fleet software integrates smoothly with all of your fleet hardware and systems. Cloud‑based solutions that are accessible from any device and update automatically reduce maintenance burdens.

4. Robust analytics and actionable insights
Collecting data is relatively simple; turning it into actionable insights is harder. Vendors should offer analytics tools that distill large data sets into meaningful metrics.

Look for dashboards that provide clear information on driver behavior, vehicle condition, compliance metrics and maintenance alerts. The system should allow custom reporting and not overwhelm managers with endless notifications. Vendors should also offer case studies demonstrating how other fleets have reduced costs and improved safety.

5. Proven reliability and innovation
Ask vendors about their track record: What is their failure rate? How do they handle downtime? Do they reinvest in research and development?

Industry experts warn that some vendors enter and exit the market quickly; longevity and a stable customer base indicate reliability. Hardware should be supported for the life of the contract. A culture of continuous improvement—taking client feedback and delivering new features—signals that a vendor is invested in long‑term partnership.

6. Strong security and privacy practices
A trustworthy telematics partner takes data security seriously. Cybersecurity best practices include regular software updates, data encryption both in transit and at rest, strong authentication controls, secure networking (e.g., VPNs) and regular security audits.

Vendors should comply with relevant data protection regulations, communicate how data is collected and used, and implement access controls to limit who can view sensitive information.

Clear privacy policies that outline what data is collected, how long it is stored and who has access build employee trust.

7. Alignment with your industry and values
Choose a partner that understands your industry’s unique challenges. Industry guides recommend evaluating a vendor’s customer base and ensuring it aligns with your sector.

Vendors should invite participation in forums and development workshops, signalling a commitment to addressing your pain points. Alignment of values—such as reliability, safety or sustainability—ensures smoother collaboration and mutual respect.

How to Evaluate and Select the Right Telematics Partner

Define goals and involve stakeholders
Start with clear objectives—improve safety, reduce costs or transition to EVs—and involve all departments that will use the data. Scorecard‑based evaluations can help prioritise requirements across departments.

Ask about scalability and innovation
Ensure the solution can expand with your fleet, support electric vehicles and automate tasks. Verify that the vendor invests in research and development and has a roadmap for new features.

Verify integration capabilities
Verify integration capabilities that go beyond basic API access and out-of-the-box integrations. Can their team handle complex system integrations with the expertise needed to understand fleet data, systems and technologies?

Review analytics and reporting tools
Ask vendors to demonstrate how their platform turns raw data into actionable insights. Look for reports and dashboards that highlight the specific key metrics you deem most important.

Examine security and privacy policies
Request documentation on data encryption, access controls, update procedures and compliance with regulations. Ensure the vendor can articulate how they address privacy concerns and provide templates for privacy policies.

Assess support and training
A reputable partner should offer dedicated account management, training sessions and proactive support. Seek references or case studies demonstrating their responsiveness and success in similar fleets.

Evaluate contract terms and hardware policies
Understand contract lengths, renewal rights and hardware upgrade policies.

Download our telematics vendor evaluation checklist for helpful questions to ask during your vetting process.

Real World Examples: Strategic Advantages

Forward-thinking fleets know that data is only valuable when it’s unified, accessible, and actionable. Many organizations invest in advanced tools—but without the right partner, they often face blind spots caused by disconnected systems and limited insight.

That’s why our approach starts with integration and ends with transformation—empowering fleets to make smarter decisions every day.

Client Example: Advancing EV Strategy with Integrated Data

Avista, a progressive utility fleet with a strong focus on sustainability and long-term planning, partnered with Utilimarc to support its electric vehicle (EV) strategy. By consolidating all fleet data into one centralized analytical environment, Avista gained the visibility needed to move faster and more strategically.

Together, we enabled:

• Meter-based maintenance scheduling
  
• Improved reporting accuracy
  
• Detailed insight into the use of specialized equipment like booms and aerial devices
  
  

With this unified view, Avista improved vehicle uptime by up to 20% and reduced maintenance and fuel costs by as much as 25%—a clear win for both operational efficiency and long-term planning.

Client Example: Gaining Visibility and Scaling with Confidence

Macro Companies, a leader in disaster response fleet operations, partnered with Utilimarc to unify and enhance its telematics data. Leveraging our expertise in Geotab integration and analytics engineering, Macro implemented a customized solution that provided:

• Real-time monitoring and advanced diagnostics
  
• Checklist-based alerting to detect and resolve issues faster
  
• Expanded hardware coverage for trailers and non-powered assets
  
• Transparent, per-vehicle billing to clarify costs and identify inactive devices
  
  

With these improvements, Macro shifted from reactive to predictive maintenance—reducing downtime, improving service reliability, and unlocking significant cost savings through smarter diagnostics and resource allocation.

One fleet leader described the impact as gaining visibility into what was once a “black hole.” That transparency not only streamlined daily operations but also gave Macro the confidence to scale.

“This solution has brought organization to chaos. We now have full visibility into our operations, enabling the growth and expansion we're seeing today.”

With reliable data and scalable systems in place, the company continues to expand into new sites and service areas—knowing Utilimarc’s solutions will grow with them.

Download the case study and read the full story.

Telematics A Partnership, Not A Product

Telematics can transform fleet operations—but only when paired with the right partner. Hidden costs, inaccurate data and poor support often stem from vendors that treat telematics as a commodity rather than a long‑term collaboration.

We demonstrate how the right partner turns data into decisions by offering proactive support, scalable integration with existing systems, advanced analytics and custom reporting, strong security practices and a commitment to transparency.

With a customer‑centric approach and deep industry expertise, we help fleets unlock real efficiency, safety and sustainability gains. By approaching telematics as a strategic partnership and choosing a provider with proven experience and a focus on analytics, fleet leaders can move beyond basic tracking to make telematics a catalyst for operational excellence.

Utilimarc’s Unique Partnership Approach

For over 20 years, we’ve helped utility, municipal, and enterprise fleets unlock the full value of their telematics investments. Unlike commodity vendors, our team goes beyond hardware—we can integrate all or any of your fleet or business systems, including maintenance, FMIS, fuel, EV charging, and enterprise resource planning.

A dedicated team of fleet data and technology experts works alongside you to configure dashboards, automate reporting, and turn raw telematics data into clear, actionable insights. Whether you're using one system or many, we unify your data so you can manage your fleet with clarity and confidence.

From tailored analytics to predictive models, we help fleets reduce costs, improve safety, and extend asset life. Most importantly, we prioritize customer success through proactive support, continuous innovation, and transparent data practices—empowering your team to harness telematics as a long-term strategic advantage.

Book a Telematics Consult with Utilimarc and discover our difference. Contact us to get started.